How to Choose an ERP: A Complete Guide

Digital transformation Published Apr 17, 2026

Selecting and implementing an ERP is an important step in structuring your company’s growth. As the number of tools increases and operations become more complex, centralizing your data and optimizing your processes becomes essential.

Learn how to select the right ERP and follow best practices to successfully implement your project and maximize its benefits.

What Is an ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning System)?

An ERP, or enterprise resource planning system, is software that centralizes a company’s data and processes within a single system. It replaces multiple separate tools with one platform, making information easier to manage and share.

The Benefits of an ERP

An ERP plays an important role in organizing business operations. It can help you:

  • Centralize real-time data in a single database;

  • Automate processes such as invoicing, inventory management and operational monitoring;

  • Improve overall visibility into business performance;

  • Support decision-making with reliable, up-to-date data.

The objective is to increase efficiency, reduce errors and manage the business more effectively.

The Main Functions of an ERP

An ERP brings several key business functions together within a single tool:

  • Finance: Accounting, invoicing and cash flow management;

  • Human resources (HR): Employee management, payroll management and absence tracking;

  • Operations: Production, inventory management and logistics;

  • Sales: Customer, order and sales activity management.

By integrating these functions, an ERP connects departments and improves operational consistency.

How Do You Choose the Right ERP?

Selecting an ERP is a strategic decision that requires a structured and progressive approach. A rigorous process helps you select a solution suited to your organization while limiting implementation risks.

1. Define Your Needs and Project Scope

The first step is to understand your business needs clearly.

  • Processes to cover: Finance, operations, sales and HR;

  • Feature prioritization: Distinguish essential features from secondary ones;

  • Requirements document: Formalize your expectations to guide the selection process.

2. Analyze the Available Solutions

The ERP market is broad, and not every solution addresses the same needs.

  • General-purpose ERPs: Comprehensive solutions such as SAP, Microsoft Dynamics and Oracle;

  • ERPs for SMEs: More flexible solutions such as Odoo, Sage and Cegid;

  • Industry-specific ERPs: Specialized tools designed for a particular sector.

3. Evaluate Flexibility and Scalability

An ERP should be able to evolve alongside your organization.

  • Future growth: Ability to support the company’s expansion;

  • Customization: Adaptability to specific processes;

  • Integrations: Compatibility with your existing tools, including CRM and business intelligence systems.

4. Choose the Right Implementation Partner

The implementation partner plays a key role in the project’s success.

  • Industry expertise: Understanding of your business environment;

  • References: Experience completing similar projects;

  • Support: Assistance before, during and after implementation.

5. Confirm the Budget and Total Cost

The cost of an ERP extends beyond the software itself.

  • Licences or subscriptions;

  • Implementation and configuration;

  • Employee training;

  • Maintenance and support.

Standard ERP vs. Custom ERP: Which Should You Choose?

Choosing between a standard ERP and a custom ERP depends directly on your business environment, processes and growth objectives. Each option has advantages and limitations that must be carefully assessed.

Standard ERP (Off-the-Shelf)

Standard ERPs are prebuilt solutions designed to address common business needs.

  • Faster to deploy: Shorter implementation time due to an existing structure;

  • Less expensive: Generally lower initial costs;

  • More limited: May offer less flexibility for highly specific processes.

This type of solution is well suited to organizations with relatively standard needs that want to implement an ERP quickly.

Custom ERP

Custom ERPs are developed or extensively customized to reflect a company’s specific circumstances.

  • Tailored: Aligned with your processes and industry-specific challenges;

  • Flexible: Scalable and customizable as your needs evolve;

  • More expensive: Higher initial investment and longer implementation time.

This approach may be appropriate for organizations with complex or differentiating processes.

How Do You Make the Right Choice?

Criteria

Standard ERP (off-the-shelf)

Custom ERP

Definition

A prebuilt solution designed to address common needs

A solution developed or extensively customized for specific needs

Deployment

Faster to deploy due to its existing structure

Longer deployment due to development or customization requirements

Cost

Less expensive, with lower initial costs

More expensive, with a higher initial investment

Adaptability

Limited customization for specific processes

Tailored to the organization’s processes and industry-specific challenges

Flexibility

Standardized and less flexible

Highly flexible and scalable

Management complexity

Easier to manage and maintain

More complex to maintain and update

Ideal use case

Organizations with standard needs seeking a fast deployment

Organizations with complex or differentiating processes

What Budget Should You Plan for an ERP Project?

An ERP project budget includes more than the price of the software. The decision requires an assessment of all long-term costs and expected benefits.

Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

The total cost of ownership (TCO) includes all ERP-related costs over several years:

  • Licences or subscriptions;

  • Implementation and configuration;

  • Data migration;

  • Employee training;

  • Maintenance and support.

A comprehensive view of the project helps you avoid unexpected costs and plan your investment more effectively.

Hidden Costs

Certain expenses are often underestimated in an ERP project:

  • Excessive customization;

  • Integrations with other systems;

  • Change management and employee support;

  • Temporary loss of productivity during deployment.

Return on Investment (ROI)

Beyond its cost, an ERP should be evaluated based on its ability to generate value.

  • Productivity gains;

  • Fewer errors and manual tasks;

  • Better decision-making;

  • Revenue growth through improved efficiency.

A well-chosen ERP is not simply an expense. It is an investment that directly supports the company’s performance and profitability.

Why Work With an Expert When Selecting Your ERP?

Selecting an ERP is a strategic decision that can significantly affect your operations and performance. Working with an expert helps structure the process, support sound decision-making and prevent costly mistakes.

Independence

An independent expert helps you assess solutions objectively, without being influenced by a particular software vendor or implementation partner.

This provides you with recommendations based on your actual needs rather than on a product someone is trying to sell.

Detailed Methodology

A structured engagement follows a clear methodology, from analyzing your needs and defining the project scope to comparing solutions and supporting the final decision.

This approach ensures that nothing is overlooked and that every aspect of the project is thoroughly assessed.

Rigour

Selecting an ERP requires an in-depth assessment based on specific criteria, including feature evaluation, cost validation, risk analysis and integration requirements.

This rigorous approach reduces uncertainty and helps protect your investment.

An External and Objective Perspective

An expert brings an outside perspective to your organization, making it possible to challenge existing practices, identify areas for improvement and step back from day-to-day decision-making.

This perspective supports more objective decisions that are better aligned with your business priorities.

Move Forward With an ERP Suited to Your Business

At Mallette, we support you throughout the selection and implementation of your ERP, taking into account your business environment and growth objectives.

Our experts help you define your needs, compare solutions, structure your project and protect your investment through a rigorous approach tailored to Quebec SMEs.

Turn your ERP project into a practical driver of performance and digital transformation.

You can count on our expertise!

  • More than 40 offices in Quebec
  • 1,600 committed professionals
  • Recognized expertise

Parlez-nous de votre projet

30 min gratuites avec un expert

Share this page:

FAQ - Choisir ERP

How Should an SME Choose an ERP?

For an SME, selecting an ERP should begin with its actual business needs, not the technology. You need to define the processes the system must support, prioritize the required features and compare solutions suited to your company’s size and industry.

An SME should prioritize a flexible, scalable solution that is straightforward to deploy, while ensuring it receives appropriate support from an experienced implementation partner.

How Much Does an ERP Cost?

The cost of an ERP varies depending on the solution selected and the project’s complexity. You should consider the total cost of ownership (TCO), including:

  • Licences or subscriptions;

  • Implementation and configuration;

  • Employee training;

  • Maintenance and support.

For an SME, an ERP project can cost anywhere from tens of thousands to several hundred thousand dollars, depending on its scope.

Cloud-Based or On-Premises ERP: Which Should You Choose?

A cloud-based ERP is hosted online and can be accessed remotely, while an on-premises ERP is installed on your organization’s own servers.

  • Cloud-based ERP: Greater flexibility and accessibility, fewer infrastructure requirements and automatic updates;

  • On-premises ERP: Greater control, but higher management and maintenance costs.

Cloud-based solutions are now generally preferred because of their flexibility and faster deployment.

Should You Choose a Custom ERP?

A custom ERP may be appropriate if your business has complex or highly specialized processes that cannot be adequately supported by a standard solution.

How Long Does an ERP Project Take?

The duration of an ERP project depends on its complexity and the size of the organization.

  • SMEs: generally between 3 and 12 months;

  • More complex projects: may take longer than 12 months.

A phased implementation helps reduce risk and supports stronger employee adoption.